Welcome to another edition of WTF Wednesday where we give really good Bad advice.
This week’s question comes from Matthew Peregoy, a.k.a, @realmattdaddy, proud owner of The Real Matt Daddy blog, who writes:
Dear IBMP,
Do you think that it’s okay to use a toddler backpack leash thingy?
Matt, like all useless information, the answer to your question begins with, “Well, that depends…”
I have a friend who used one because her autistic child wouldn’t hold her hand and, when combined with a lack of awareness of surroundings, it was a safety thing. Fair enough, but what about the rest of us?
Let’s explore this in a bit more detail.
There are some clear benefits of using leashes on toddlers. One of the more obvious is that keeping a boy on a short leash from an early age is great preparation for eventual married life.
A leash can ensure that your child can have hours of “outside” time while tied to the tree in the front yard without fear that they’ll run off chasing other children or pooping on neighbors’ lawns. Just be sure to leave a bowl of water for them. It would be cruel and demeaning to leave them out there on a leash without water.
It also allows you to spend more quality time with your child. This is possible because you can tie them up in front of the restaurant while you enjoy your meal. As you know, leaving a child in a hot car can completely ruin their hair. Our solution, of course, is usually to leave them at home with a 2-litre bottle of Coke and the TV remote while we go bar hopping or visit relatives for the weekend. The leash gives you the freedom to take them along.
A leash can even be good for your health; it makes it much easier for your toddler to keep up when you’re out jogging. That means you don’t have to keep doubling back to tell her to hurry up.
So, you can see there are some pretty good reasons to use a leash. If you do choose to use one, consider training your toddler to do a consistent sit/stay before taking your child out on the leash for the first time. And bring a lot of treats—that will help your toddler work on heeling. With time and patience, you’ll be walking a well-trained child that all your friends will envy.
As for whether it’s okay, you’re in shape, enjoying some good family time, and your child’s getting lots of fresh air. What could be wrong with that?
Problem solved. You’re welcome!
Got a question for WTF Wednesday? Drop it into the comments below!
Sammy
January 11, 2012
Thanks, it was a great bedtime story. But now with all that talk of walking and running my dog got the leash for me and is taking me for a walk. And she makes me carry my own poop bag too.
JSD
January 11, 2012
Best poop bag solution I’ve seen is to tie the bag to the dog’s collar and let them carry it home. The dog was trained as a pup, and carried her load for 13 years. 🙂
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
Really, you have to carry your own? Dude, you’ve got to work on training that dog of yours!
Also, I don’t recommend letting your dog read this blog — they get all kinds of bad ideas…
BrainRants
January 11, 2012
The leash is an obvious good thing. What’s your take on choke chains?
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
Choke chains…yeah, that’s a controvercial one. A lot of those things are made in China by child laborers. I don’t think it would be ethical to put one on my kid.
JSD
January 11, 2012
Very funny! I just wish the kiddie leashes were around when my boys were young…would have avoided one particular police alert and an hour of sheer terror.
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
Yikes! I never understood what real terror was until I had a kid and thought, even briefly, that I may have lost him.
Jaja Shah-Mohen
January 11, 2012
I was just thinking about this today!!
My toddler is hyperactive and it doesn’t really help now that I have a 2-months old in tow. This really does put things into perspective about walking my son. I mean, taking him out for a walk.
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
You know, maybe you can take care of both issues: Let the hyperactive toddler take the 2-month old on walks. that way the toddler burns off some energy and they get some good bonding time while you have a much-needed cup of coffee and a good book. Seriously, I don’t see why I’m not rich and famous, what with all my brilliant advice and stuff.
Kaiwin
January 11, 2012
Do recommend liver treats? Yummy!
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
That’s a nice, healthy treat. So…no. The time to give your child healthy treats is when they’re laying around playing video games–that’s when the healthy stuff does the most good. Snausages are a good alternative; they have cartoons of smiling dogs on the bags and kids love that.
krismerino
January 11, 2012
Very funny!
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
🙂
Angela@BeggingTheAnswer
January 11, 2012
I’ve seriously considered getting one of those leash things for my toddler. Her nickname is “destruct-o” Problem solved 🙂
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
Yeah, a leash is way more convenient than bubble-wrapping everything.
therealmattdaddy
January 11, 2012
Thank you so much for answering that burning question. Can you recommend a good length for the tie-out to the tree? Have you tried those shock collars yet? I love technology…
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
It depends a bit on where the neighbor’s kid is tied up. you want them just out of reach of each other so the lines don’t get tangled up.
You know, my wife has been using shock collars on me now for a number of years. Of course, she uses them to keep me OFF the property rather than on it. I say it’s worth a try. There’s a guy named GOF that hangs out here on ocassion–he’s got a lot of experience using technology to aid in child-rearing. We’re going into business together on an IBMP branded cattle prod. He might have some thoughts on the shock collar thingy…
becomingcliche
January 11, 2012
Harness, not choke chain, right?
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
Well, I’d probably stick with the harness until your kid can do a consistent sit/stay. Seems a bit inhumane to use a collar until they can do that…
Hajra
January 11, 2012
Hey,
Lol! I don’t have kids, but my sister has two of them and they are getting a little out of control! Might be time to put them on the leash… eh? 😉
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
Hey there, Hajra! How you been? Yeah, probably a good time to get them used to the leash before they think they can just have the run of the house every time they come visit…
Thanks for coming by!
Janie Jones
January 11, 2012
We used a toddler “leash” for a bit when the spud was young, because as soon as she discovered the joy of walking (at 11 months) she quickly became loudly and hysterically intolerant of sitting in a stroller or shopping cart. And, from the joy of walking it was a short trip to the joy of long distance wind sprinting. Seriously, the spud, at 13 months, could get from the deli at the Walmars to the garden center before you could say this sh*tty cart has a bum wheel. Unfortunately, the spud even more quickly became loudly and hysterically intolerant of the restriction of a toddler leash, so we were just screwed any which way you approached the issue. I got looks of disgust from the rest of the adult populace no matter what I did.
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
You really can’t win. People kinda don’t like when your kid runs in front of busses, but they don’t like screaming kids on leashes either. I say people who give other parents looks of disgust for parenting the way the see most appropriate should have whatever it is removed from their backside, framed, and posted on their wall as a reminder of their dickishness.
Grace
January 11, 2012
Hahah this is great. I once saw a mom with her kid on a leash and her dog roaming free behind her. It was an interesting sight.
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
I would have died laughing!
whatimeant2say
January 11, 2012
I suddenly realized who I need to blame for the poop I keep finding on our lawn. Nobody thought to include kids in our stupid leash ordinance.
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 11, 2012
Hahaha! Poor city planning. A real shame 😉
Anntrea (@DoodlesandJots)
January 12, 2012
I can’t bet the dog comparison out of my head either – the answer for me is no – I get the safety aspect but still no!
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 12, 2012
Could you be just a bit more clear? Are you saying “maybe” or “possibly”?
felicexo
January 12, 2012
Very funny post!! 🙂
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 13, 2012
🙂 .
Alexis
January 13, 2012
I have worn nothing but running shoes for the past 5 years because at any minute I may be required to take off at a dead sprint to prevent the imminent demise of one my beloveds. While the leash may seem impractical (my 2 are never close enough together so which one do I let loose?) I would never judge another parent for using them.
If nothing else my sprinting skills have increased dramatically.
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 13, 2012
I hear ya! As much as WTF Wednesday is about snarky crappy advice, it should not be taken as an actual endorsement or condemnation of any of the techniques discussed. To be honest, I can’t actually quite figure out how people do manage more toddlers than they have available hands…
~m
January 14, 2012
My oldest was put on a leash, for a couple months, when she was about 18 months or so. She went through a time period that strollers just weren’t acceptable, and I couldn’t keep a hold of her. That child *loved* everyone and moved faster than light….I used it at large, moving crowd events (rare) after we nearly lost her once. Child would take off with/after someone (or something) with glee. And yes, I was judged many times for both NOT being able to stop her running, and then for having a leash.
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 14, 2012
Yup. We’ve heard a few folks say their kid was/is unsafe in those situations and the leash was the best option. My son was always lazy enough to be quite happy in a stroller. For that matter, he’d still be in one if they made them his size. 😉
I’ve learned people will judge you no matter what you do as a parent. Bottom line is you kept your girl safe and something tells me she’s not going to judge you badly for that–and hers is the only opinion that really matters. 🙂
Alicia
January 14, 2012
LOL – I am still laughing so hard, I’m crying… Luckily for us we never needed one when our DS was young, seems I have to find a short leash for him now (he’s 8yo) to keep him away from various sources of endless entertainment 🙂
Your articles must be the funniest I’ve ever read on parental advice… keep them coming, we all (parents or not) need them 🙂
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 14, 2012
Thanks for the kind feedback, Alicia. You might want to get one of those retractable thingies for your 8 year-old. That way you can extend it so he can pee in private without having to take him off the leash. You just reel it back in when you want him to heel or when those sources of endless entertainment are within arms reach.
Thanks for reading!
cath
January 18, 2012
Wish there had been leashes when my kids were little. Would have saved me a lot of leg work. 😀
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
January 18, 2012
And money on running shoes, too, I bet.