Welcome to this week’s instalment of WTF Wednesday where I don’t need to be an expert; I just need to know more than you.
This week’s question comes from a good friend who writes:
Dear IBMP,
Is getting a dog good preparation for having kids?
Yes, of course getting a dog is good preparation for having kids. They have many things in common and a properly chosen dog will, with just a few exceptions, teach you just about everything you need to know about having kids. And they don’t live as long so if you mess up you can always start again within 10 to 12 years. Your average kid lives a lot longer so you’re pretty much stuck with them once you bring them home.
Let’s take a quick look at some of the things you can learn from a dog about raising children:
- Young dogs have lots of energy. So do children. Both species will tend to use that energy for evil instead of good if left unchecked. Learning to properly crate them and walk them regularly will ensure a happy, healthy child and protect your furniture from undue harm at the same time.
- Both dogs and children require obedience training. Dogs are considerably easier to train but will help you lay a strong foundation in the principles of obedience and prepare you for the more difficult task of training your child.
- Dogs are always hungry and dog ownership is great preparation for having a growing child. A good rule of thumb is that it takes roughly three great Danes to equal a single male teenager’s consumptive habits.
- Both species are quite fond of treats and can be easily bribed. Raising a dog is a great way to get used to always having something on hand to bribe your child. Note, however, that it has been my experience that Bacon Bites work better with most children than Snossages.
- Both numbers three and four lead to the obvious conclusion that the better fed dogs and children are, the better behaved they will be.
- While dogs are generally better at sharing than children, they do provide the opportunity to practice breaking up silly fights over stupid toys. Dogs will soon teach you that breaking up fights should be done with a long, sturdy stick or a fire hose set on full pressure. Not all parents agree with this technique so be prepared to grab your child and run immediately following its application.
- Drool. Both species generate copious amounts. Just get used to it.
- While dogs are better at waiting until you are not around and therefore smarter about not getting caught, both will test your patience when it comes to jumping on the furniture.
- Dogs are excellent preparation for stepping on toys left in inconvenient and/or dangerous places. Dogs do not generally play with Legos (one of the worst offenders among children’s toys) but stepping on a squeaky toy while sneaking up the stairs at 2:00 in the morning after a night out with the boys can be far more damaging in the long run.
There are, of course, many more things about raising a child that dog ownership can prepare you for. We’ve only had time to touch on a few here. I’m guessing our readers will be happy to contribute some of their own.
It is also important to note some of the things that dog ownership will not prepare you for—the differences between dogs and children.
- Dogs don’t talk back.
- Dogs are better at sitting and staying.
- Dogs usually do things the first time they’re told.
- Dogs clean up after themselves at dinnertime.
- Dogs wipe their own butt right from the start . . . actually, what do they do? Ew. Never mind.
- Dogs are grateful for just about everything you do.
- Dogs love you whether you buy them Legos or not.
- Dogs don’t ask why.
- Dogs don’t complain nearly as much as kids do when you put them in the crate during dinner parties.
- 10. Dogs don’t ever require “The Big Talk” (although a crowbar is sometimes required to pry your dog off of your guest’s leg).
- 11. Birthdays are much less expensive and way easier to plan.
- 12. The 10-second rule for food on the ground does not apply for dogs.
- 13. Dogs are way easier to potty train.
OK, so maybe there are a lot of exceptions but clearly dog ownership is good preparation for having children. Of course, looking back through the differences one begins to wonder why we would want children at all. But then I’m reminded that one thing kids can do that dogs can’t is pick up all the poop in the backyard. And I’m sure as hell not going to do it.
Problem solved. You’re welcome!
Do you have a question you’d like answered? Ask it below and if yours is used, you’ll receive a copy of the IBMP Dictionary of Parenting Terms ebook in whatever digital format you’d prefer.
Oh, and one other thing: The I’ve Become My Parents Dictionary of Parenting Terms is available for download for just $.99 this week only! You don’t need a fancy ebook reader so you have no excuse. Go use a tiny bit of that Amazon or Barnes and Noble gift card and have a laugh. ‘Kay?
lifeloveandbaby
December 28, 2011
Ha! Funny you should address this topic – having “practiced” with my dog first before having a baby, this idea has been brewing in the back of my mind for some time now. You definitely covered the important stuff. One thing I’d add is that a dog prepares you for endless whining and begging – for food or otherwise!
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
December 29, 2011
Yes, this is true. Although now that my dog is getting older, he’s learned that begging gets him nowhere (my son, on the other hand, continues to try to no avail). Now the dog just follows me around with that certain look on his face, waiting for me to “accidentally” drop something on the floor.
becomingcliche
December 28, 2011
Everything I know about raising kids I learned from training my dogs. For real. But I disagree on the talking back. I have a PBGV (wire-haired basset) who has a bad case of “lastword-itis.”
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
December 29, 2011
Ooh, I’ve never experienced doggy lastword-itis but if it’s anything like kiddie lastword-itis I am truly sorry for your misfortune. 😉
Ms Mary
December 28, 2011
I’ve had and have dogs. I don’t have kids. Wonder if the former is the reason for the latter? Number 3 (Great Danes) is hilarious – I’m sharing with a male friend with three sons. (I hear music … and see 3 animated feet tapping … Wah?) As for the OTHER number 3, they do not do what they’re told the first time – unless there’s a treat involved or they are trained by someone with OCD. (Repetition repetition repetition … ad infinitum.) Good post, Barmy. Thanks for the belly laughs!
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
December 29, 2011
Hi there Ms Mary. I have to admit that we were a bit on the OCD side with our pooch. Now that he’s a good ripe 8 year-old, he’s pretty good at doing things the first time we ask — way better than the 2-legged 10 year–old.
Oh, and tell your friend I’m sorry to hear of his triple affliction. I’m pretty sure they created Costco for people like him…
whatimeant2say
December 28, 2011
I tried to crate my daughter when we left the house, but my husband didn’t think that was a good idea. He spoils her way too much.
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
December 29, 2011
He’s obviously vying for the favorite parent designation. He’s going to be sorry when that girl grows up to be a healthy young woman who thinks she can just sleep in her room any night she pleases. Plus, there’s one more shrink out of a job…
Ann
December 29, 2011
Great illustration – AGAIN!!! Really funny – every point – and so insightful!!! One more advantage to kids (but not a guarantee) is that they will take care of you when you get old (although if dogs could they would and probably more willingly – never mind, why do we have kids???)
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
December 29, 2011
Thanks Ann! Not sure I’v got the same natural talent for drawing and design that you display on your blog but I’ve been really enjoying working at it.
You make a good point about caring for us parents when we get old, and I agree completely that if dogs could, they would do so more willingly. 🙂
nevercontrary
December 29, 2011
Dear IBMP,
I am about to start potty training my daughter. Any tips, advice, or suggestions?
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
December 29, 2011
Thanks for the question! It’s a good one 🙂
ptigris213
December 29, 2011
You forgot some!
Dogs can be spayed or neutered so you needn’t worry about one coming home pregnant.
Dogs don’t need to go to the prom.
You can sell a dog if you get tired of it.
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
December 30, 2011
Haha! All three are awesome additions! Thanks.
GOF
December 30, 2011
Is there some sort of “Child Pound” or “Kid Refuge Center” where I can dump my kid?
I think I got it all wrong and need to start all over again with a dog.
Barmy Rootstock (IBMP)
December 30, 2011
Yeah, see, this is the problem; people get all upset about people trying to return their kids. You could always keep making kids until you get one right. At some point the older ones can deal with the younger rejects and you can focus on the new ones…